16. May 2023
Henriette zu Doha
Biochar | biosolids | PFAS | phosphorus fertilizer | Sewage Sludge | Uncategorized

Carbo­niza­tion of sewage sludge removes pollut­ants of high ecolo­gical and human health impact

Recy­cling sewage sludge, through pyro­lysis, results in high-quality biochar, contai­ning valuable phos­phorus, an essen­tial nutrient for plant growth. Moreover, carbo­niza­tion offers muni­ci­pa­li­ties a safe and profi­table solu­tion in terms of the circular economy as signi­fi­cant rene­wable energy is gene­rated and reused, while the phos­pho­rous-rich biochar provides both agri­cul­tural bene­fits and seques­ters carbon, when given into the soil.
However, controlled carbo­niza­tion has another signi­fi­cant advan­tage: it sani­tizes toxic and conta­mi­nated sewage sludge, thus protec­ting people and nature.

Computer-controlled process

The core of the PYREG tech­no­logy is the patented reactor in combi­na­tion with the down­stream FLOX combus­tion chamber (“FLOX” stands for flame­less oxida­tion). In the reactor, the raw mate­rial is heated largely in the absence of air at high tempe­ra­tures of around 500 to 700 °C for several minutes.  The computer-controlled process para­me­ters – such as speed of convey­ance of the feed mate­rial, tempe­ra­ture and air supply, is the key to recy­cling success. In the process, the phos­phorus remains comple­tely available for plants. And moreover: This treat­ment of sewage sludge offers great poten­tial for the removal of many pollut­ants of high ecolo­gical and human health impact.

Carbo­niza­tion destroys feedstock pathogens

Sewage sludge origi­nates mainly from human excre­ments. Natu­rally, the sludge contains spores, patho­gens, and pyro­gens, which are of public health concern.[1] Stan­dard hygie­niza­tion of sewage sludge (e.g. heating of the sludge to 70 °C), does not elimi­nate all these contaminants.

The process condi­tions of pyro­lysis (> 500 °C for more than three minutes) are much harsher even than approved steri­liza­tion condi­tions. Accor­dingly, pyro­lysis elimi­nates all pathogens[2] and pyro­gens contained in sewage sludge – inclu­ding bacteria, fungi, vira, spores, para­sites, anti­biotic resis­tance genes etc. The final product, i.e. the biochar, is free of threats for public health.

Pyro­lysis elimi­nates micro­pol­lut­ants from sewage sludge

Incre­asing concern is raised regar­ding the spre­a­ding of sewage sludge on farm­land, due to the presence of micro­pol­lut­ants in sludges. Recent scien­tific rese­arch has demons­trated that pyro­lysis will destroy or remove several types of micropollutants:

Organic pollut­ants (e.g. phar­maceu­ti­cals, hormone disrupting molecules):

Scien­tific evidence shows that at suffi­ci­ently high pyro­lysis tempe­ra­tures (> 500 °C) and long dura­tions (> 3 min), all refe­rence organic conta­mi­nants and micro­pol­lut­ants were comple­tely or nearly comple­tely degraded or driven off the solid mate­rial. A study published in 2019 by the German Ministry of Envi­ron­ment (Bundesumweltamt)[3] analyzed the resi­dues of various phar­maceu­tical bioso­lids after pyro­lytic treat­ment above 500 °C. After the process, all of the inves­ti­gated phar­maceu­ti­cals were below the detec­tion limit. The authors conclude: “With thermo-chemical treat­ments (i.e. pyro­lysis) a complete destruc­tion of the phar­maceu­tical resi­dues is achieved. No further tech­nical treat­ment measures are necessary.”

PFAS:

Per- and Poly­fluo­ro­alkyl Subs­tances (PFAS) are elimi­nated by the process of pyro­lysis. Kundu et al. (2021)[4] found that > 90 % of PFOS and PFOA in sewage sludge were destroyed in a pyro­lysis-combus­tion inte­grated process. Evidence from the US EPA Office of Rese­arch and Deve­lo­p­ment (2021)[5] carried out on the US-based company Bioforcetech’s commer­ci­ally installed PYREG plant shows that pyro­lysis at 600 °C for 10 minutes and combus­tion of pyro­lysis gases at 850 °C elimi­nate PFAS from sewage sludge. Biof­orce­tech (2021)[6] has reported 38 PFAS compounds that were all kept at or removed to below detec­tion limit in the biochar in their pyro­lysis and pyro­lysis gas burning process.

PAH:

Spre­a­ding sewage sludge on agri­cul­tural land is very common in Europe, although sludges poten­ti­ally contain elevated levels of toxic poly­cy­clic aromatic hydro­car­bons (PAH). Properly desi­gned pyro­lysis processes can elimi­nate these chemical compounds, resul­ting in biochar with a PAH content below limit values or even detec­tion limits: Moško et al. (2021)[7] demons­trated that slow pyro­lysis at > 400 °C removes more than 99.8 % of the studied PCB, PAH, endo­crine-disrupting chemi­cals, and hormonal compounds. The authors state: “High tempe­ra­ture (> 600 °C) slow pyro­lysis can satis­fac­tory remove organic pollut­ants from the resul­ting sludge-char, which could be safely applied as soil improver”.

Pyro­lysis elimi­nates micro­pla­stic from sewage sludge

Rese­arch indi­cates that sewage sludge is a sink for micro­pla­stic. Thus, effec­tive reduc­tion of the plastic frag­ments is critical for poten­tial dispersal.[8] Ni et al. (2020)[9] found that Poly­ethy­lene and poly­pro­py­lene, the two most abun­dant micro­pla­s­tics in sewage sludge, were enti­rely degraded when the pyro­lysis tempe­ra­ture reached 450 °C.Total concen­tra­tions of micro­pla­stic were reduced from 550.8 – 960.9 to 1.4 – 2.3 particles/g at pyro­lysis tempe­ra­tures of 500 °C. No micro­pla­stic with a particle size of 10-50 μm remained.

To illus­trate the beha­vior of plastic during high tempe­ra­ture treat­ment (for example during pyro­lysis), the thermal decom­po­si­tion curves of PE and PP are shown in Figure 1. PE and PP thermal degra­da­tion shows a dramatic mass loss between 400 °C and 500 °C, while above 500 °C “the mate­rial degraded comple­tely without leaving any noti­ceable residue.”[10] PET, a highly rele­vant plastic type regar­ding sewage sludge, starts to decom­pose at a tempe­ra­ture above 450 °C and tran­si­tions to the gas phase. PET decom­po­si­tion is termi­nated in less than one minute (α = 1) at tempe­ra­tures above 500 °C[11]. The cracked gases are of high calo­rific value and can be used for energy produc­tion. Thus, the pyro­lysis of sewage sludge is a good method to drasti­cally reduce micro­pla­stic in the envi­ron­ment.

 Figure 1: TG scans of PE and PP measured at a constant heating rate in two diffe­rent test envi­ron­ments: inert atmo­sphere and in air.[12]

Sources:

[1]  Huygens, D., Garcia-Gutierrez, P., Orveillon, G., Schil­laci, C., Delre, A., Orgi­azzi, A., Wojda, P., Tonini, D., Egle, L., Jones, A., Pistocchi, A. and Lugato, E., Scree­ning risk assess­ment of organic pollut­ants and envi­ron­mental impacts from sewage sludge manage­ment, EUR 31238 EN, Publi­ca­tions Office of the Euro­pean Union, Luxem­bourg, 2022, ISBN 978-92-76-57322-7 (online), doi:10.2760/541579 (online), JRC129690.

[2]  Paz-Ferreiro, Jorge, Aurora Nieto, Ana Méndez, Matthew Peter James Askeland, and Gabriel Gascó. 2018. “Biochar from Bioso­lids Pyro­lysis: A Review” Inter­na­tional Journal of Envi­ron­mental Rese­arch and Public Health 15, no. 5: 956. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph15050956

[3]  Bundes­um­weltamt (2019) Arznei­mit­tel­rück­stände in Rezy­klaten der Phos­phor­rück­ge­win­nung aus Klär­schlämmen, Umwelt­for­schungs­plan des Bundes­mi­nis­te­riums für Umwelt, Natur­schutz und nukleare Sicher­heit, Forschungs­kenn­zahl 3715 33 401 0, UBA-FB 002724 (https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/1410/publikationen/2019-03-29_texte_31-2019_arzneimittelrueckstaende-klaerschlamm_v2.pdf)

[4]  Kundu, S., Patel, S., Halder, P., Patel, T., Mary­bali, M. H., Pramanik, B. K., Praz-Ferreiro, J., Figuei­redo, C. C., Berg­mann, D., Sura­pa­neni, A., Megharaj, M., Shah, K., Removal of PFASs from bioso­lids using a semi-pilot scale pyro­lysis reactor and the appli­ca­tion of bioso­lids derived biochar for the removal of PFASs from conta­mi­nated water, Environ. Sci.: Water Res. Technol., 2021, 7, 638–649

[5]  Gullet, B., EPA PFAS inno­va­tive treat­ment team (PITT) findings on PFAS destruc­tion tech­no­lo­gies, EPA Tools & Resources Webinar February 17, 2021

[6]  https://ccag.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/BFT_FEB_2020-1.pdf

[7]  Moško J, Pohořelý M, Cajt­haml T, Jere­miáš M, Robles-Aguilar AA, Skoblia S, Beňo Z, Inne­ma­nová P, Linhar­tová L, Mich­alí­ková K, Meers E. Effect of pyro­lysis tempe­ra­ture on removal of organic pollut­ants present in anae­ro­bically stabi­lized sewage sludge. Chemo­sphere. 2021 Feb;265:129082. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.129082. Epub 2020 Nov 23. PMID: 33309446

[8]  Charles Rolsky, Varun Kelkar, Erin Driver, Rolf U. Halden, Muni­cipal sewage sludge as a source of micro­pla­s­tics in the envi­ron­ment, Current Opinion in Envi­ron­mental Science & Health, Volume 14, 2020, Pages 16-22, ISSN 2468-5844, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.coesh.2019.12.001.

[9]  Ni, B., Zhu, Z., Li, W., Yan, X., Wei, W., Xu, Q., Xia, Z., Dai, X., & Sun, J. (2020). Micro­pla­s­tics Miti­ga­tion in Sewage Sludge through Pyro­lysis: The Role of Pyro­lysis Tempe­ra­ture. Envi­ron­mental Science and Tech­no­logy Letters, 7, 961-967.

[10]  Sudip Ray, Ralph P. Cooney, chapter 9 – Thermal degra­da­tion of polymer and polymer compo­sites, Myer Kutz, Hand­book of envi­ron­mental degra­da­tion of mate­rials (third edition), william Andrew publi­shing, 2018, pp. 185-206, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-52472-8.00009-5

[11]  Osman, A.I., Farrell, C., Al-Muhtaseb, A.H. et al. Pyro­lysis kinetic model­ling of abun­dant plastic waste (PET) and in-situ emis­sion moni­to­ring. Environ Sci Eur 32, 112 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12302-020-00390-x https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Reaction-progress-a-versus-the-temperature-for-the-PET-pyrolysis-where-the-coloured-and_fig1_343994995.

[12]  Sudip Ray, Ralph P. Cooney, chapter 9 – Thermal degra­da­tion of polymer and polymer compo­sites, Myer Kutz, Hand­book of envi­ron­mental degra­da­tion of mate­rials (third edition), william Andrew publi­shing, 2018, pp. 185-206, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-52472-8.00009-5

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DAS KÖNNTE SIE AUCH INTERESSIEREN

What exactly are carbon removal credits and how do they work?

What exactly are carbon removal credits and how do they work?

WHAT ARE CARBON CREDITS? A carbon credit is a tradeable unit representing the avoidance, reduction or removal of one metric ton of CO2e from the atmosphere. Organizations and individuals can use these credits to oset their greenhouse gas...